Writing about a photograph by Edward Ranney called Canyon del Muerto, Arizona, 1987:
"Ed lives in northern New Mexico, about two hundred miles east of Canyon de Chelly (which includes Canyon del Muerto). Many notable photographers have preceded him there, including Timothy O'Sullivan, John Hillers, Edward Curtis, Laura Gilpin, and Ansel Adams. To make a strong new picture at that location is a remarkable achievement.
"How did he do it? Probably not by walking the canyon rim with any preconceived notion (if you begin with an idea you're usually beat before you start). To make a photograph of this quality he must have trusted to good fortune and to his eyes, looking with full attention at the water-marked sandstone, the cottonwoods, and the slanting light...this specific place and moment. Only from within that focus is it likely that he would have been allowed to see more, a landscape unified by what appears to be part of an X, the unnamable.
"Perhaps there is also in the picture a suggestion of outstretched arms. I have never asked the photographer if he sees that too, but it might be an appropriate reading by any of us. Art is important when nothing less will suffice, a reconciliation."
- Art Can Help, p. 33














































































